A thing of beauty is a joy forever... or so I was joyed to see the Akshardham Temple. But this article made me think... think thrice..
(thanks to Alok and Blog Bang)
God lives elsewhere
So how much space does god need to call it his home? How many crores
does god want us to spend on him so that he can possess a swanky,
sprawling mansion which dominates the skyline? So what will god do in
this huge expanse, move from room to room? Looking for what, inner
peace, outer silence, inner silence, bitter truth? Or will he play golf
or ride a horse and gaze at the distances of the private property he
possesses, till the eye can see, like landlord-princes in old European
paintings? Is god terribly afraid of darkness? Does he suffer from
insomnia? Is he a sleepwalker? If not, why does he need hundreds of
jazzed up lights all night in a city so starkly short of power and in a
nuclear power country where half the population still don't have
electricity (or enough to eat, below that mythical poverty line)? So
why does god need this rolling-in-wealth real estate?
And if he resides in the quietness of our hearts, in every word, bird,
leaf and leaf storm, in every butterfly, ant and inanimate object, in
rippling rivers, evening tides, moon shadows, mountain trees, and if he
lives in the winter wind which we breathe and if he is formless and
infinite, objective and etherised, essence and presence, then why does
he need a lavish palace in concrete as his residence on earth? Whose
god is this god?
Is god terribly afraid of darkness? Does he suffer from insomnia? Is he
a sleepwalker? Why does he need this rolling-in-wealth real estate?
President APJ Kalam, a pro-bomb scientist, inaugurated the opulent
Akshardham temple in east Delhi recently, modelled on the Akshardham
temple in Ahmedabad. Accompanying him was Dr Manmohan Singh, a man of
austerity and scholarship. Also present was the original patron of this
mega religiosity, 'pseudo secularist' LK Advani, who not only fights
elections from Gandhinagar, but compulsively backs Narendra Modi who
presided over the post-Godhra genocide. Find the links: the Akshardham
complex is controlled by the powerful, cash-rich Swaminarayan sect,
mostly based in Gujarat, with strong NRI links among the Friends of
vhp/bjp. And it won't be a misnomer to say that they, like the vhp
NRIs, are orthodox Hindutva loyalists, top-heavy in the caste society.
This pink sandstone dham of godliness, sprawled over 100 acres, as
mushy newspaper reports tell us, cost Rs 200 crore, (some say Rs 400
crore) and it is 141 feet high, with 234 ornate pillars, 20,000 gods,
sculptured flora and fauna, a vedic village, markets etc, the works.
God's own little sacred space. Next to a river which is dead, a dead
Yamuna, killed by urbanity's insatiable insensitivity, now nothing but
a nullah, a dirty repository of sewage and shit, static, with plastic
and polythene bags full of flowers and offerings to god floating in the
quagmire, like a rotten memory which refuses to die.
Across the temple, beyond the high, protective, iron fences, like an
apartheid fortress, live the other children of god. The invisible row
of proles, in sub-human ghettos. On Diwali, outside their thatched
homes, they smeared the courtyard with cow dung, some made alpana with
mashed rice, the little feet of Lakshmi, and lighted a diya with a few
drops of oil. Days after the festival of lights, the diya still burns
in this dark expanse under the Nizamuddin bridge, as if telling the
dazzling Akshardham adorned with hundreds of lights, that yes, god
lives elsewhere. In the ignited minds and wings of fire of democracy's
black irony. God's own democracy.
7 comments:
wow. what a thought. thank you so much for sharing that.
cargwaps
thanks for the appreciation.
Bhaskar
yo da .. read this stuff on your blog man ... somehow doesn't go down well with me .. i mean to ask why people make temples as big as akshardham is to a great extent improper or stupid .. and to say that " the Akshardham complex is controlled ...... orthodox Hindutva loyalists, top-heavy in the caste society. " is no less than pig shit dude ... have you tried to collect all the details about this NGO have ya ... have tried to know wat its support base is why it has such a big following .. why they don't highlight their achievements ... have ya understood the true meaning or reason because of the aksdham has been constructed ... never express ur opinion just by going thru a website or by reading a few pamphelets .. ... go and interact with the support group
... one more thing dude aksdham is not a temple its a monument to india its culture to its artist artisians it a monument to indians and their talent
monk punk
if you had read calmly, you would have noticed that Aks was just a case in point.. to me, it is much broader.. its against all things wasteful..
i have not much idea on the good deeds by the people in question.. but then, good deeds dont cancel out wasteful ones.
to me, it is simple.. the crores spent in building Aks/temple/church/mosque, could have easily lit some poor families' kitchen stove.
why celebrate the past and let the present rot?
and dude.. you know something called 'the right to one's views/opinions'?? as much you are free to have your own views/opinions, so do i.
And I rest the case here.
monk punk
if you had read calmly, you would have noticed that Aks was just a case in point.. to me, it is much broader.. its against all things wasteful..
i have not much idea on the good deeds by the people in question.. but then, good deeds dont cancel out wasteful ones.
to me, it is simple.. the crores spent in building Aks/temple/church/mosque, could have easily lit some poor families' kitchen stove.
why celebrate the past and let the present rot?
and dude.. you know something called 'the right to one's views/opinions'?? as much you are free to have your own views/opinions, so do i.
And I rest the case here.
Bhaskar
hey man ... chill out .. first of all i ain't not knowing no punk.
chill madi da ... now each one of us has the right to express his views/opinions ... however i personally believe that you should be able to defend your stand .. at the same time try and reason out with the other person.
now, many people believe that instead of you know making big temples n all .. why not donate it to poor people !! i used to part of this very group, used to be.
i don't know abt any other org., and hence i won't defend them. BAPS, the ngo which constructed aksdham .. that i know .. still i will try not to defend them. i just hope to reason it out with you ...
when you construct a house you hire labour, eng. , mason n all.. you pay them .. and you give them repec, for you know better then them that you need them, you appreciate their ability. you give them repect ... n with money you pay them it gives satisfaction.
when someone under takes a task with end-of-the-day expenditure of 450 crores, employing 7000 sculptors, 4000 labourers ... he helps to keep the stove burnibg .. he sees that the stomachs are filled and the minds are not ideal. now when for 5 yrs you have a gurranteed pay, you are if not happy then tension free ... i think.
it doesn't stop here man, the people working in stone mines in
hey man ... chill out .. first of all i ain't not knowing no punk.
chill madi da ... now each one of us has the right to express his views/opinions ... however i personally believe that you should be able to defend your stand .. at the same time try and reason out with the other person.
now, many people believe that instead of you know making big temples n all .. why not donate it to poor people !! i used to part of this very group, used to be.
i don't know abt any other org., and hence i won't defend them. BAPS, the ngo which constructed aksdham .. that i know .. still i will try not to defend them. i just hope to reason it out with you ...
when you construct a house you hire labour, eng. , mason n all.. you pay them .. and you give them repec, for you know better then them that you need them, you appreciate their ability. you give them repect ... n with money you pay them it gives satisfaction.
when someone under takes a task with end-of-the-day expenditure of 450 crores, employing 7000 sculptors, 4000 labourers ... he helps to keep the stove burnibg .. he sees that the stomachs are filled and the minds are not ideal. now when for 5 yrs you have a gurranteed pay, you are if not happy then tension free ... i think.
it doesn't stop here man, the people working in stone mines in india nad abroad .... people in the transportation buisness ... people in tourism and hotel ... people in taxi, auto n all ... the list is not endless but still not small .... things contribute ... you contribute .. sometimes directly ... most of the times indirectly.
to reply man .. for none shall rest till he has convienced the other.
in spirit
Post a Comment